Expired Tender Jordan ICB TOT Ref. 31948569

Consultancy Firm to Provide End of Project Tender - 31948569

Tender notice from Jordan, published on 01 Apr 2019.

Executive Summary

The WORLD VISION INTERNATIONAL has issued a Tender notice for the procurement of a Consultancy Firm to Provide End of Project Evaluation in the Jordan. This Tender notice was published on 01 Apr 2019 and is scheduled to close on 07 Apr 2019, with an estimated Tender value of Refer Document. Interested bidders can access detailed Tender information, eligibility criteria, and complete bidding documents by referencing TOT Ref No. 31948569, while the tender notice number is and Register on the platform.

Key facts

Summary
Consultancy Firm to Provide End of Project Evaluation
TOT Ref. No.
31948569
Document Ref. No.
Country
Jordan
Notice type
Tender
Competition
ICB
Publication date
01 Apr 2019
Bid deadline
07 Apr 2019
EMD
Refer Document
Tender value
Refer Document
Purchaser ownership
-
Financier
Other Funding Agencies

CPV classification

Purchaser details

Purchaser contact is for registered users

Login to see details

Tender details

Tenders are invited for Jordan: Consultancy Firm to Provide End of Project Evaluation for BMZ Aleppo Project.
https://drive.google.com/open?id=10Nn__EJJH96cbVS43KYyRGPP4NKtQave
Evaluation Terms of Reference

Providing health and WASH services for conflict-affected Syrians in Aleppo governorate
World Vision International

i. Table of Contents
Summary. 3

Project Background and Rationale. 4
Indicators to be Evaluated: 7

Evaluation Purpose, Objectives and Use. 7

Evaluation Users: 8

Evaluation Methodology. 9

Management of the Evaluation. 12

Process & Quality Assurance. 13

Logistics. 13

Tentative Evaluation Timeframe. 14

Outputs & Deliverables. 14

Budget 14
ii. Affirmation

Except as acknowledged by the references in this paper to other authors and publications, the contents described in this terms of reference consists of our own work, undertaken to secure funding, implement the activities, describe and advance learning, as part of the requirements of World Vision-s Monitoring, Evaluation, Accountability and Learning System.
Primary quantitative and qualitative data collected throughout the evaluation process remains the property of the communities and families described in this document. Information and data must be used only with their consent.
Carla Lewis, MEAL Manager, March 2019
Summary

Project Number:
208827
Country:
Syria
Area of implementation
Syria, Aleppo governorate, A-zaz district
Project title:
Providing health and WASH services for conflict-affected Syrians in Aleppo governorate
Duration:
24 months
Start Date:
1 June 2017
End Date:
30 April 2019
Primary Sector of Intervention:
WASH and Health
Type of Implementation:
Direct Implementation
Evaluation requirements:
Final Evaluation
Donor:
BMZ
Budget:
2.5 Million Euros
Evaluation Methodology:
Quantitative: Household survey
Qualitative: Key informant interviews (KIIs), focus group discussions (FGDs)
Desk review of secondary data and sources
Evaluation Users:
WVI, WV Germany, BMZ
Evaluation Dates:
March- April 2019
Anticipated draft evaluation report release date:
30th April 2019
Project Background and Rationale

Within Syria, 13.5 million people, including four million children, are in urgent need of humanitarian assistance. There are 6.3 million Internally Displaced People (IDPs), and 4.9 people in need in hard-to-reach and besieged locations (Humanitarian Needs Overview 2017, OCHA). Humanitarian needs in Northern Syria, which hosts the largest number of IDPs in the country, remain the most acute, particularly in Aleppo governorate (HNO 2017). At the start of the project, following fighting in Jarablus and Al Bab, the number of people displaced in Northern Syria increased rapidly. The total number of IDPs in Aleppo governorate totalled over 175, 000. The continuing campaign to retake Ar-Raqqa city contributed to the increase of the number of IDPs in the north substantially; with up to 350, 0000 people in total estimated to be affected by the offensive. In Northern Syria, 84, 702 displacements were reported from 1 January - 28 February 2017, the majority of whom were fleeing the ongoing fighting in Al Bab (CCCM Cluster Displacement Snapshot). The majority of IDPs fled to A-zaz district, specifically Aghtrin sub-district that borders Al Bab, which received 5, 361 people since the beginning of 2017, and Suran sub-district, which received 4, 830 people.
The destruction of infrastructure during the fighting caused a serious lack of essential services in Al Bab and surrounding areas. The rehabilitation of infrastructure was considered crucial as it ensured essential services and dignified living conditions for returning civilians. At the start of the project, IDPs ere often required to travel long distances to obtain services such as health and water and sanitation, in addition access to basic services, e.g. in WASH or health, was hampered by destroyed/ damaged infrastructure, lack of staff and supplies as well as overloaded services. Attacks against hospitals, water networks, and electricity plants were also commonplace (HRP, 2017).
Overall the proposed intervention targeted the populations in A-zaz district, specifically A-zaz, Aghtrin and Suran sub-districts and Jarablus District. The project targeted both IDPs who have had to flee recent fighting in Aleppo, Menbij and Al Bab as well as host community members. Additional beneficiaries included the local council, its water authority as well as the local health directorate from targeted WASH related capacity building efforts.
Project-s Beneficiaries and Geographical Coverage
The project targeted men, women, boys and girls in A-zaz, Aghtrin and Suran sub-districts, Aleppo Governorate, both host community members and IDPs. A detailed breakdown, according to the WASH and Health measures is shown in the table below.
Table 1: Project Targets for WVI interventions
Location
Sector
Men
Women
Boys*
Girls*
IDPs
Total
Akhtrin, Aleppo
WASH
11, 429
11, 948
14, 027
14, 546
7, 950
51, 950
Suran, Aleppo
WASH
3, 674
3, 841
4, 509
4, 676
4, 000
16, 700
A-zaz, Aleppo
Health
3, 370
3, 659
1, 814
1, 957
N/A
10, 800
Total
18, 473
19, 448
20, 350
21, 197
11, 950
79, 450
*younger than 18 years old
WASH
? Individuals benefitted from safe drinking water, solid waste collection, and improved sanitation systems are men, women, girls, boys, including the vulnerable, and the disabled, in the villages: Zayadiyeh, Aghtrin, and Turkmen Bareh in Aghtrin sub-district; and Kafra, Kafr Ghan and Dweibeq in Suran sub-district. In August 2018, the activities expanded to Tal Aar, Arshaf and Eastern Rural Maraee.
? Hygiene promotion in schools and communities targeted men, women, girls, and boys, particularly school children between the ages of 5 and 17 in the villages: Zayadiyeh, Aghtrin, and Turkmen Bareh in Aghtrin sub-district; and Kafra, Kafr Ghan and Dweibeq in Suran sub-district. In August 2018, activities expanded to Tal Aar, Arshaf and Eastern Rural Maraee.
? WASH activities targeted 68, 650 individuals in Aghtrin and Suran sub-districts and Maree sub-district, including 11, 950 internally displaced people (IDPs)
Health
? Health activities targeted patients in need of CT scan services, such as those with trauma and complicated pathologies
? Health activities targeted 10, 800 patients in Al Ahly hospital, in A-zaz city through receipt of CT scans, as the CT scanner can operate up to 20 patients per day for 18 months. Al Ahly hospital receives approximately 10, 000 consultations and admissions per month and has a catchment population of 350, 000. However, due to lack of CT scanners available in the wider area, the catchment population for this service is 1.5 million.
? Three medical staff were hired and trained in operating the CT scanner, referral mechanisms and humanitarian principals: one radiologist and 2 radiologist assistants.
These target groups were chosen based on analysis of geographical gaps, particularly in the wake of recent displacements, and as such this project intends to address existing gaps and needs not currently covered by the local authorities and NGOs. Displaced Syrians living in A-zaz district were particularly vulnerable, as the district continues to experience regular influxes of IDPs. Consultations were held with the local authorities such as the local council, the water authorities, and the municipality of all targeted areas.
Table 2: Number of beneficiaries reached per community by WVI
Governorate
District
Sub-District
Community
Health
WASH
Aleppo
Jarablus
Jarablus
Jarablus
4, 177
0
Azaz
Souran
Dweibeq
0
7, 500
Kafr Ghan
0
10, 350
Kafra
0
12, 000
Maree
Eastern Countryside of Marie
0
17, 876
Akhtarin
Akhtarin
0
27, 718
Turkman Bareh
0
13, 460
Al_Zyadia
0
13, 870
Ghroor
0
5, 250
Arshaf
0
8, 994
Tal A'ar
0
15, 434
Sandara
0
7, 000
Dodian
0
8, 000
Due to the rapidly changing context, several amendments to the project design and target villages have taken place since initial project design and baseline. A project revision took place in May 2018 resulting in a change to target villages. In February, 2019 a second revision was submitted. In March 2019 World Vision formed a new partnership with Syria Relief (SR) to expand project interventions in Aghtarin. SR will provide WASH humanitarian assistance to 14, 160 host, IDPs, and returnees vulnerable people affected by the crisis in 14 communities as detailed in the table below. The measures concentrate on rehabilitating infrastructure in the area of water, sanitation and solid waste disposal as well as on trengthening the capacity of the Sandara Water Unit to ensure water quality and introduce a tariff system for water.
Table 3: Number of beneficiaries targeted by SR WASH interventions (March-April 2019)
Sub District
Community
Men
Women
Girls
Boys
TOTAL
Aghtrin
Ahmadiyha
24
26
29
31
110
Aziziyeh
213
233
252
272
970
Kardish
638
696
754
812
2900
Mezraat Shahin
290
317
343
370
1320
Qazam - Qesset Jak
211
230
250
269
960
Sandara
627
684
741
798
2850
Shabanyiha
136
149
161
174
620
Tal Battal
231
252
273
294
1050
Tal Sheer Aazaz
209
228
247
266
950
Othmaniya
59
65
70
76
270
Khaliliya
66
72
78
84
300
Omariya
55
60
65
70
250
Kara Koz
304
331
359
386
1380
Mansora
51
55
60
64
230
TOTAL
3115
3398
3682
3965
14160
The consultant should take into account the changes in project design when designing the sampling approach and appropriate data collection methods.
Intervention Hierarchy
Overall objective: Reducing the vulnerability of targeted conflict-affected people in the Aleppo governorate through increased access to essential diagnostic services and improvement of their living conditions in regards to WASH.
Outcome 1: Strengthened diagnostic capacity of the health system in rural Aleppo at the main referral hospital in A-zaz (Al Ahly Hospital)
Output 1.1:** Al Ahly Hospital is equipped with one new and reliable CT scanner
Output 1.2:** Medical staff is available and trained in order to conduct enhanced diagnosis services at Al Ahly Hospital in A'zaz
Outcome 2: The emergency and mid-term WASH needs of the population of Aghtrin and Suran sub-districts in Aleppo governorate are met through improved access to safe drinking water & access to improved sanitation services
Output 2.1:** Rehabilitation and operation of water systems in A-zaz.
Output 2.2:** Rehabilitated sewage system networks in A-zaz
Output 2.3:** Increased capacity of local council to implement solid waste management system
Output 2.4: Beneficiaries have increased awareness and adoption of good hygiene and sanitation practices in A-zaz and Al Bab
Proposed Intervention Description:
The proposed project contributed towards strengthening the delivery of WASH and Health services for conflict-affect population in Aleppo (A-zaz, Aghtrin, Suran and Maree sub-districts). World Vision implemented this project directly with its staff on the ground and in coordination with the local councils, the water units and the health directorate. The health activities aimed to reduce complications from common illnesses, trauma, chronic and acute diseases in A-zaz. Procuring and installing a CT Scan is expected to improve the quality of primary health care integrated with trauma and chronic disease management services in Jarablus. A CT Scan was procured in Turkey and sent to Syria to Jarablus hospital serving 20 patients a day. To operate and run the radiology unit, one radiologist and two radiologist assistants will be recruited and trained on the use of CT Scan but also on humanitarian principles and referral mechanisms to/from other health facilities. The project also covered the salary of the recruited medical staff.
The WASH activities focused on infrastructural activities to serve the emergency and mid-term WASH needs of the population of Aghtrin, Suran and Maree sub-districts in Aleppo governorate. To increase access to safe drinking water and decrease the water borne diseases, the project will rehabilitate six water systems. The water systems were operated and maintained and water was tested. This project took a sustainable approach to transition Operations and Maintenance (O&M) to local water authorities by slowly decreasing the percentage of O&M support over several months with the aim to handover O&M fully to local authorities by project completion. To complement this transition, water authorities were trained in operating the water systems and in water quality treatment. To increase access to sanitation services, this project rehabilitated and extended existing sewage system networks, rehabilitated landfills, distributed rubbish bins to communities and support garbage collection trucks with fuel and salaries for workers. These components also included training local authorities on a tariff system for garbage collection as well. Finally, to increase awareness and good hygiene practices, hygiene promotions at community level were organized
Indicators to be Evaluated:

Summary of Objectives
Description
Indicators
Outcome 1
Strengthened the diagnostic capacity of the health system in rural Aleppo specifically main referral hospital in Jarablus City (Jarablus Hospital)
% of target population benefiting from the health services
increase of target population access to specialized health diagnostic services
Outcome 2
Improved access to safe drinking water & access to improved sanitation services in Aghtrin and Suran sub-districts in Aleppo governorate
% of target HHs that use an improved drinking water source
% of population with access to improved sanitation facility
% of people benefiting from a cleaner environment as a result of solid waste disposal service at least twice per week
% increase in respondents who report washing hands in three out of five critical times
Evaluation Purpose, Objectives and Use

Purpose
The final evaluation will be conducted to examine the efficiency, effectiveness, timeliness, relevance, and potential impact of the project, to allow measurement of project achievements and to provide recommendations for future similar projects. The evaluation should take into consideration the project duration, existing resources, political and environmental constraints. This evaluation will also identify strengths and weaknesses in the project design, strategy, and implementation as well as lessons learned.
The purpose of this evaluation is to:
· Provide outcomes indicators measurement and comparison to baseline values;
· Determine if the project has achieved its stated objectives and explain why/why not;
· Determine the impact of the project in terms of sustained improvements achieved;
· Provide recommendations on how to build on the achievements and the possible avenues/intended objectives and results of a second phase of the project
· Document lessons learned, success stories, and good practices in order to maximize the experiences gained.
· Identify areas where strategic collaboration could add value in a second phase of operations
The evaluation should focus on the efficiency, effectiveness, timeliness, relevance and potential impact of the project, specifically answering the following questions:
Effectiveness: To what extent has the project achieved predicted results at outcome level? What changes have been observed in project indicators since baseline and what has been the reasons for this change? How effective have beneficiary accountability mechanisms been?
Relevance: Was the project-s design adequate to address the problem(s) at hand? To what extent was the project sensitive to the different needs of women, men, girls and boys and to vulnerable groups in the population?
Efficiency: Were project results achieved in the most efficient and cost-effective way? To what extent has partner coordination helped or hindered the efficiency of the project?
Impact: What have the wider intended and unintended effects of the project been on individuals, households, targeted communities and institutions? How likely is it that the impact of the project will be sustained after the project ends and why?
After examining the findings according to the evaluation criteria, lessons learned and recommendations should be drawn. The consultant should provide information on the economic/political/financial conditions that should exist, staff and partner capacities, required stakeholder participation, and other factors that should be in place to inform the design of future operations.
Developing the measurement and analytical framework to refine and operationalize the questions posted above, will be done in close cooperation between World Vision and the consultant.
Evaluation Users:

This evaluation will be used to:
· Support accountability of WVI vis-à-vis the donor on the outcomes of the Action and the usage of the funds provided through the provision of the evaluation report.
· Support learning on the management of the project through the process of the evaluation and the discussion of the evaluation results.
The evaluation will serve as a learning resource providing evidence for planning, programming and replication of similar interventions for the following local and international stakeholders:
Donor: The evaluation will be submitted to BMZ to highlight the effectiveness and impact of the implemented project. The report will show to what extent the objective and the respective sub-objectives are met. It offers the opportunity for WVI to be accountable towards the its donors as the process will be documented in details and information will be generated based on the perception of the community.
WV Germany: As the Support office is in direct contact with BMZ, the evaluation report will also be presented to WV Germany to show the effectiveness and impact of the implemented project and highlight any challenges faced at the level of implementation. The Support Office will be also engaged in the evaluation process by providing feedback and approval on the ToR as well as the evaluation report.
WVI Syria Office: The data collected from the evaluation will inform WVI on the technical and operational successes and challenges faced throughout the program implementation. The evaluation will further contribute to generating lessons learned and recommendations that should guide future similar interventions.
Main partners and collaborators who will first be involved in the evaluation process and provide valuable input throughout the process about their collaboration with WVI and their experience in the project as a whole.

The finding will also be useful for them as they provide information about the effectiveness and impact of the intervention in their community and recommendations that might be relevant to consider in the coming phase, after the project has ended.
The evaluation will also help ensuring accountability for all beneficiaries and community members in the areas of operations.
Evaluation Methodology

The evaluation methodology is informed by the M&E plan specified during program design; in particular the design should use the sampling approach, tools and methods used at baseline to enable statistically sound comparison of baseline and endline results, where feasible. Due to the changes in project design since baseline the consultant is required to propose the most appropriate sampling and data collection approach that is sensitive to the revisions while producing statistically robust evidence. The evaluation methods should be a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods involving the relevant project stakeholders, and beneficiaries at the community level. Data collection methods may include but are not limited to secondary data information (project documents will be provided by WVI), surveys with target population in villages, Key Informant Interviews (KII) and focus group discussions (FGD) with main stakeholders.
Primary data collection is expected to comply with recognized ethical principles. Survey data are expected to be collected on smartphones or tablets, using ODK, Kobo, SMAP or similar applications, and processed electronically. The consultant will provide the cleaned primary data set to World Vision and grants World Vision rights of storage and further usage. The consultant is expected to:
· Provide an inception report to be reviewed by National Office, Regional Office and Support Office prior to data collection.
· Provide a time schedule, a breakdown by location and a breakdown of resources needed for primary data collection in the locations covered under this project;
· Hire, train and supervise enumerators, which must include both men and women, and care for their provisions and security;
· Obtain the necessary permissions for gathering primary data from the relevant authorities.
Mixed methods approach: The report should triangulate data from primary and secondary sources. The primary data are from quantitative and qualitative sources (listed above) that provide information from various beneficiary perspectives; the secondary data will be drawn from a review of key project documents.
Secondary data Collection: Based on the agreed upon analytical framework, WVI will provide the consultant with access to project documents relevant for the evaluation. The consultant is expected to research and include additional secondary sources in the analysis as needed. World Vision can support with relevant additional secondary sources as available.
Primary data collection - sampling approach:
Quantitative sampling: The evaluation should employ the household survey sampling methodology used at baseline to allow for comparison, where possible. During baseline a two-phased proportional stratified random sampling approach was used with the primary sampling unit being the household with a sample frame of total population of the original targeted communities per project/sector. The table below shows the sample drawn at baseline:
Table 4: Sampling frame at baseline
Gov
District
Intervention
Sub-district
Target Communities
Target
Requied Sample Size
Actual Surveys
FGDs
KIIs
Aleppo
A-zaz
WASH
Akhtreen
Zayadiyeh
59, 900
140
140
4
6
Akhtreen
140
140
4
3
Turkmen Bareh
140
140
3
2
Suran
Kafra
20, 700
138
138
6
11
Kafr Ghan
139
139
4
1
Dweibeq
138
138
6
6
Jarablus
Health
Jarablus
Jarablus
64, 042
210
210
6
4
Al Bab*
126
0
0
0
Ghandora*
84
84
3
4
Total
144, 642
1255
1129
36
37
* Communities not targeted by project after revision due to the security context
The consultant should adopt a sampling approach that mirrors the baseline sample so that statistical comparisons can be made, and in addition include a representative sample of the target communities added after baseline took place using the same two-phased proportional stratified random sampling approach
Sample size: The below sample size equation is hereby suggested to calculate the required sample size for those communities not included at baseline
n = [ ] where:
Z = The z-score corresponding to the degree of confidence with which it is desired to be able to conclude that an observed change of size for p and q would not have occurred by chance (Z = 1.96)
p = Estimated prevalence of indicator in the population (p = 50%)
q = 1-p, population not presenting with indicator
D= Design effect for a complex, clustered, sample (D = 2.0)
d = Precision/margin of error, as fraction of 1 (d = 5%)
The estimated level of an indicator to be measured as a proportion is 0.5 (P1 =0.5), which is the most conservative assumption. A confidence level of 95% (Z = 1.96) and a design effect of 2.0 is used, with a margin of error of 5% incorporated. Using the sample size formula above plus with 10% oversample, in each sub-district Table 5 outlines the sample to be drawn from communities that were not included at baseline:
Table 5: Sample size for WVI intervention communities without baseline data
Governorate
District
Sub-District
Community
Beneficiaries Reached
Sample size
Maree
Eastern Countryside of Marie
17, 876
415
Akhtarin
Ghroor
5, 250
419
Arshaf
8, 994
Tal A'ar
15, 434
Sandara
7, 000
Dodian
8, 000
It should be noted that since the activities in this project have benefitted both host communities and IDPs, the sample must include both groups proportionally.
Given the short-term interventions in SR intervention villages it is suggested that a qualitative approach is taken in these villages (see Project Description for details of these communities)
Qualitative sampling:
Key Informant Interviews: Key informant interviews should be conducted with stakeholders including members of Local Councils, water station engineers, hospital managers, medical staff and project staff. While the evaluator is not required to use identical KII sampling frame to baseline, deviation should be justified. For reference, 37 KIIs were conducted at baseline, and distributed as illustrated in the Table 4 above.
Focus Group Discussions: Focus group discussions should be conducted to gain a deep understanding of beneficiary perspective and explanations of change and their perceptions of the project as per the research questions. At baseline seven communities were selected from the sampling frame to cover a range of geographic locations, including rural and urban, with participants randomly selected by doing a village walk. Focus groups with women, men, girls and boys should be conducted separately. While the evaluator is not required to use identical FGD sampling frame to baseline, deviation should be justified. For reference, 36 FGDs were conducted at baseline, and distributed as illustrated in the Table 3 below.
Quality of Evidence
The evaluation should ensure that evaluation design and data analysis is to a sufficient standard to meet industry standards around evidence as per the Bond Evidence Principles of voice and inclusion, appropriateness, triangulation, contribution and transparency (https://www.bond.org.uk/resources/evidence-principles ). Guidance on how to meet the minimum standard of each criteria can be found in the document below:
Management of the Evaluation

Team Members and Roles
Role
Evaluation Phase
Responsibilities and tasks
Consultant
Planning
· Develop and submit the evaluation methodology (sample selection, quantitative & qualitative methodology) via inception report. A template for the inception report will be provided by WV.
· Draft evaluation matrix
· Conduct desk review of key documents in the documentation briefing book
· Finalize question matrix by gathering information needs and feedback from relevant stakeholders and prioritize evaluation objectives
· Develop data collection tools based on the tools used during the initial baseline
· Gather feedback on tools from evaluation advisors and conduct pilot testing of the tools where relevant
Data Collection & Analysis
· Recruit and train data collectors if relevant for both quantitative and qualitative data collections
· Conduct quantitative and qualitative data collection (supported with data collectors where relevant)
· Supervise and assure the quality of quantitative data collection
· Supervise data entry clerk
· Set up a plan for quantitative data analysis, conduct in depth data analysis and interpretation of results
· Provide weekly feedback to WVI team
Reporting, Validation & Follow up
· Draft the Evaluation report
· Prepare power point presentations of the main findings
· Finalize the Evaluation report based on feedback from WVI team
· Submit a 2 pager summary fact sheet (in English and Arabic) to be disseminated to relevant stakeholders.
Data Collectors
· Carry out quantitative and/or qualitative data collection as relevant
· Report to evaluation consultant
MEAL Manager
Planning
· Develop evaluation TOR
· Develop evaluation work plan
· Follow-up on recruitment of evaluation consultant
· Develop documentation briefing book
· Provide feedback on evaluation methodology and matrix
· Approve the methodology and ensure its quality
Data Collection & Analysis
· Provide feedback on data collection tools
· Follow up with the consultant on data collection and analysis, ensure quality of data collection
· Provide feedback on data analysis and ensure the quality of interpretation
Reporting, Validation & Follow up
· Provide feedback on draft evaluation report
· Share internally the draft version of the report and follow up on the feedback received
· Co-facilitate stakeholder interpretation workshop with consultant
· Review and share final version of the report
Project Manager & team
Planning
· Provide input on TOR and research questions
· Provide documents for literature review
Data Collection & Analysis
· Provide feedback on data collection tools
· Coordinate with consultant in relation to data collection logistics
Reporting, Validation & Follow up
· Provide feedback on draft evaluation report and recommendations
Support Office
Planning
· Provide input on TOR and research questions
Data Collection & Analysis
· Provide feedback on data collection tools & inception report
Reporting, Validation & Follow up
· Provide feedback on draft Evaluation report and recommendations
Process & Quality Assurance

WVI MEAL team will ensure the quality of all deliverables through the following means:
Clarity: During the inception phase WVI team will clarify the needs and expectations of this exercise. The consultant will have to provide a technical design and operational plan detailing how the survey or data will be collected and reported within a specified timeframe. Evaluation design will be shared and reviewed by WVI team to ensure its relevance and appropriateness and that the design is adequate to meet the minimum standards of evidence quality (as per Bond Evidence Principles).

Communication: The consultant will have to conduct regular skype calls with WVI team to review assignment progress and critique draft tools and report as required. As well as to discuss any areas of concern such as difficulties, possible solutions, and important events affecting the evaluation. While WVI team will maintain regular exchange and follow-up with the consultant on all operational and substantial issues, provide necessary support to any troubleshooting issues faced by the consultant and ensure quality assurance of the services delivered by the consultant.

· Timing: The timeline for the evaluation exercise will allow sufficient time for review of all draft deliverables and for revisions to these deliverables to make sure that feedback was acted upon.
· Reporting: The consultant will have to submit a comprehensive evaluation report which complies to WVI-s reporting standards and addressing all WVI teams- comments and feedback on the first draft.
· Global Standards: The service provider will have to ensure that its work complies with WVI Syria Office standards.
Logistics

The recruited consultant will be in charge of finalizing logistical issues related to the transportation to the different areas where data collection will be completed.
Tentative Evaluation Timeframe

Responsible person
Tasks
Tentative timeline
MEAL Manager
Compile all project documents and share with the consultant
5th April 2019
Evaluator
Desk review of project documents
12th April
Evaluator
Inception report including draft tools and send to WVI for feedbac
17th April
Evaluator
17th April
MEAL Manager
Compile all feedback and send to the evaluator
20th April
Evaluator
Send Final modified tools to WVI
23rd April
Evaluator
Train enumerators
24th-26th April
Evaluator
Finalize data collection
4th May
Evaluator
Data Cleaning and Analysis
10th May
Evaluator
Draft report
10-17th May
Evaluator
Submission of the report to the MEAL manager
17th May
MEAL Manger
Circulating the draft report to key stakeholders
17th-24th May
MEAL manager
Send consolidated comments to evaluator
24th May
Evaluator
Modify the report as per WVI comments
24th-26th May
MEAL Manager
Dissemination of the final evaluation report
27th May
Outputs & Deliverables

The expected deliverables throughout the process of evaluation include:
Evaluation Methodology (including Evaluation Matrix) as part of inception report
Budget Breakdown
Validated and tested data collection tools
Thematic in-depth analysis of qualitative data
Data sets (software outputs)
Notes and transcription of KII and FGDs
Tabulation of results including descriptive analysis, associations and comparison with baseline data
Evaluation Report (in English, based on Template provided by WVI)
2 pager fact sheet summary (in English and Arabic)
Findings interpretation meeting to WVI staff
All collected data is legally owned by WVI and the consultant is expected to hand over all data sets and notes of the interviews or FGD to the organization. The Consultant shall maintain in confidence and protect all information provided to him/her by WVI, its employees, and beneficiaries. The consultant may only disclose the extent necessary to perform the evaluation.
Safe guarding & data confidentiality
The external evaluator, along with all enumerators, will be required to sign and follow World Vision International´s global safeguarding policy and behavior safe protocols, which will be provided to the research team selected.
All primary data collected by this evaluation process is to remain confidential and is not to be shared with third parties.
Budget

The consultations fees available for this end of program evaluation will include transportation, logistics and accommodation fees identified by the consultant, as well as recruitment of data collectors/data entry clerks and data collection, data entry, translation fees and report writing. The accommodation fees will include venue rental, meals and coffee breaks for FGDs. A budget breakdown needs to be submitted by the consultant.
Conflict of Interest
The service provider must be impartial and independent from all aspects of management or financial interests in the entity being monitored. During the tenancy period, the evaluation should not be employed by, serve as director for, or have any financial or close business relationships with any of WVI-s entities being monitored. The service provider and the Third Party Monitors sub-contracted (if it applies) should declare any potential conflicts of interest which may affect or compromise their ability to conduct neutral and independent service.
Such conflicts of interest may include, but are not limited to:
Business interests in a community where a WVI partner is delivering a programme.

Business interests or financial gains from WVI through other activities or projects where applicable.

Financial, family, political and business affiliation with an organisation with whom WVI has a partnership.

In such a scenario or similar, the service provider is expected to declare the conflict of interest to the contractor who will present to WVI. Declaration of conflict of interest will not be viewed negatively but will be considered in the programming of activities. Failure to declare a conflict of interest may be considered and may lead to a review of the expected deliverables from the monitor or the service provider, thus with a possible negative impact on the contract of the monitor or service provider.
Required Qualifications and Expertise of the consultant/consultancy firm
Registered legally as a company in Syria or with full ability to operate in Syria.

A minimum of 5 years of demonstrated professional experience delivering services in the country or the similar complex environment.

· Have expertise and experience in social science research, including mixed methods and notably quantitative and qualitative primary data collection methods
· Have expertise and experience in research, monitoring and evaluation in humanitarian emergency response contexts, preferably related to the Syria crisis, as well as related technical standards
· Have proven experience in conducting participatory qualitative and quantitative evaluation studies with superior analytical skills
Demonstrate proven capacity to carry work in different geographical zones in Syria.

Proven capacity to engage experienced team to carry out data collection.

Experience of working with the UN system, bilateral donors and NGOs in delivering monitoring, evaluation, data collection, analysis and reporting activities.

· Have a good knowledge of quantitative data collection software (such as Kobo, SMAP) and statistical packages (such as SPSS)
· Have excellent report writing skills
· Have excellent written and spoken English and Arabic
· Hold a minimum educational qualification equivalent to a master´s degree in a relevant field.
Willing to avail senior management to discuss progress against contract deliverables.

Capacity to arrange all logistical and security arrangements independently for field work (the contracted service provider is expected to organise its logistics and security arrangements).

The supplier has to ensure that they are not linked to any part of the conflict

Application
The consultant should submit a proposal comprising the following:
· A technical proposal which indicates how the consultant is going to undertake the activities highlighted in the ToR, indicative budget with initial indication of the enumerators and timeframe required
· A capacity statement detailing the consultant´s ability to deliver a quality evaluation report within the given timeframe, including an overview of relevant work and technical experience
· At least 2 samples of previous relevant works undertaken, including at least 1 evaluation report that was 100% led by the lead consultant
· Contact details for 2 references for similar assignments done not more than 2 years ago
· CVs of the key personnel on the evaluation team
· A financial budget with explanations about the line items
· Any appendices the consultant sees as relevant to the application.
Evaluation Terms of Reference
Providing health and WASH services for conflict-affected Syrians in Aleppo governorate
world vision international
i. table of contents
summary. 3
project background and rationale. 4
indicators to be evaluated: 7
evaluation purpose, objectives and use. 7
evaluation users: 8
evaluation methodology. 9
management of the evaluation. 12
process & quality assurance. 13
logistics. 13
tentative evaluation timeframe. 14
outputs & deliverables. 14
budget 14
ii. affirmation
except as acknowledged by the references in this paper to other authors and publications, the contents described in this terms of reference consists of our own work, undertaken to secure funding, implement the activities, describe and advance learning, as part of the requirements of world vision-s monitoring, evaluation, accountability and learning system.
primary quantitative and qualitative data collected throughout the evaluation process remains the property of the communities and families described in this document. information and data must be used only with their consent.
carla lewis, meal manager, march 2019
summary

project number:
208827
country:
syria
area of implementation
syria, aleppo governorate, a-zaz district
project title:
providing health and wash services for conflict-affected syrians in aleppo governorate
duration:
24 months
start date:
1 june 2017
end date:
30 april 2019
primary sector of intervention:
wash and health
type of implementation:
direct implementation
evaluation requirements:
final evaluation
donor:
bmz
budget:
2.5 million euros
evaluation methodology:
quantitative: household survey
qualitative: key informant interviews (kiis), focus group discussions (fgds)
desk review of secondary data and sources
evaluation users:
wvi, wv germany, bmz
evaluation dates:
march- april 2019
anticipated draft evaluation report release date:
30th april 2019
project background and rationale

within syria, 13.5 million people, including four million children, are in urgent need of humanitarian assistance. there are 6.3 million internally displaced people (idps), and 4.9 people in need in hard-to-reach and besieged locations (humanitarian needs overview 2017, ocha). humanitarian needs in northern syria, which hosts the largest number of idps in the country, remain the most acute, particularly in aleppo governorate (hno 2017). at the start of the project, following fighting in jarablus and al bab, the number of people displaced in northern syria increased rapidly. the total number of idps in aleppo governorate totalled over 175, 000. the continuing campaign to retake ar-raqqa city contributed to the increase of the number of idps in the north substantially; with up to 350, 0000 people in total estimated to be affected by the offensive. in northern syria, 84, 702 displacements were reported from 1 january - 28 february 2017, the majority of whom were fleeing the ongoing fighting in al bab (cccm cluster displacement snapshot). the majority of idps fled to a-zaz district, specifically aghtrin sub-district that borders al bab, which received 5, 361 people since the beginning of 2017, and suran sub-district, which received 4, 830 people.
the destruction of infrastructure during the fighting caused a serious lack of essential services in al bab and surrounding areas. the rehabilitation of infrastructure was considered crucial as it ensured essential services and dignified living conditions for returning civilians. at the start of the project, idps ere often required to travel long distances to obtain services such as health and water and sanitation, in addition access to basic services, e.g. in wash or health, was hampered by destroyed/ damaged infrastructure, lack of staff and supplies as well as overloaded services. attacks against hospitals, water networks, and electricity plants were also commonplace (hrp, 2017).
overall the proposed intervention targeted the populations in a-zaz district, specifically a-zaz, aghtrin and suran sub-districts and jarablus district. the project targeted both idps who have had to flee recent fighting in aleppo, menbij and al bab as well as host community members. additional beneficiaries included the local council, its water authority as well as the local health directorate from targeted wash related capacity building efforts.
project-s beneficiaries and geographical coverage
the project targeted men, women, boys and girls in a-zaz, aghtrin and suran sub-districts, aleppo governorate, both host community members and idps. a detailed breakdown, according to the wash and health measures is shown in the table below.
table 1: project targets for wvi interventions
location
sector
men
women
boys*
girls*
idps
total
akhtrin, aleppo
wash
11, 429
11, 948
14, 027
14, 546
7, 950
51, 950
suran, aleppo
wash
3, 674
3, 841
4, 509
4, 676
4, 000
16, 700
a-zaz, aleppo
health
3, 370
3, 659
1, 814
1, 957
n/a
10, 800
total
18, 473
19, 448
20, 350
21, 197
11, 950
79, 450
*younger than 18 years old
wash
? individuals benefitted from safe drinking water, solid waste collection, and improved sanitation systems are men, women, girls, boys, including the vulnerable, and the disabled, in the villages: zayadiyeh, aghtrin, and turkmen bareh in aghtrin sub-district; and kafra, kafr ghan and dweibeq in suran sub-district. in august 2018, the activities expanded to tal aar, arshaf and eastern rural maraee.
? hygiene promotion in schools and communities targeted men, women, girls, and boys, particularly school children between the ages of 5 and 17 in the villages: zayadiyeh, aghtrin, and turkmen bareh in aghtrin sub-district; and kafra, kafr ghan and dweibeq in suran sub-district. in august 2018, activities expanded to tal aar, arshaf and eastern rural maraee.
? wash activities targeted 68, 650 individuals in aghtrin and suran sub-districts and maree sub-district, including 11, 950 internally displaced people (idps)
health
? health activities targeted patients in need of ct scan services, such as those with trauma and complicated pathologies
? health activities targeted 10, 800 patients in al ahly hospital, in a-zaz city through receipt of ct scans, as the ct scanner can operate up to 20 patients per day for 18 months. al ahly hospital receives approximately 10, 000 consultations and admissions per month and has a catchment population of 350, 000. however, due to lack of ct scanners available in the wider area, the catchment population for this service is 1.5 million.
? three medical staff were hired and trained in operating the ct scanner, referral mechanisms and humanitarian principals: one radiologist and 2 radiologist assistants.
these target groups were chosen based on analysis of geographical gaps, particularly in the wake of recent displacements, and as such this project intends to address existing gaps and needs not currently covered by the local authorities and ngos. displaced syrians living in a-zaz district were particularly vulnerable, as the district continues to experience regular influxes of idps. consultations were held with the local authorities such as the local council, the water authorities, and the municipality of all targeted areas.
table 2: number of beneficiaries reached per community by wvi
governorate
district
sub-district
community
health
wash
aleppo
jarablus
jarablus
jarablus
4, 177
0
azaz
souran
dweibeq
0
7, 500
kafr ghan
0
10, 350
kafra
0
12, 000
maree
eastern countryside of marie
0
17, 876
akhtarin
akhtarin
0
27, 718
turkman bareh
0
13, 460
al_zyadia
0
13, 870
ghroor
0
5, 250
arshaf
0
8, 994
tal a'ar
0
15, 434
sandara
0
7, 000
dodian
0
8, 000
due to the rapidly changing context, several amendments to the project design and target villages have taken place since initial project design and baseline. a project revision took place in may 2018 resulting in a change to target villages. in february, 2019 a second revision was submitted. in march 2019 world vision formed a new partnership with syria relief (sr) to expand project interventions in aghtarin. sr will provide wash humanitarian assistance to 14, 160 host, idps, and returnees vulnerable people affected by the crisis in 14 communities as detailed in the table below. the measures concentrate on rehabilitating infrastructure in the area of water, sanitation and solid waste disposal as well as on trengthening the capacity of the sandara water unit to ensure water quality and introduce a tariff system for water.
table 3: number of beneficiaries targeted by sr wash interventions (march-april 2019)
sub district
community
men
women
girls
boys
total
aghtrin
ahmadiyha
24
26
29
31
110
aziziyeh
213
233
252
272
970
kardish
638
696
754
812
2900
mezraat shahin
290
317
343
370
1320
qazam - qesset jak
211
230
250
269
960
sandara
627
684
741
798
2850
shabanyiha
136
149
161
174
620
tal battal
231
252
273
294
1050
tal sheer aazaz
209
228
247
266
950
othmaniya
59
65
70
76
270
khaliliya
66
72
78
84
300
omariya
55
60
65
70
250
kara koz
304
331
359
386
1380
mansora
51
55
60
64
230
total
3115
3398
3682
3965
14160
the consultant should take into account the changes in project design when designing the sampling approach and appropriate data collection methods.
intervention hierarchy
overall objective: reducing the vulnerability of targeted conflict-affected people in the aleppo governorate through increased access to essential diagnostic services and improvement of their living conditions in regards to wash.
outcome 1: strengthened diagnostic capacity of the health system in rural aleppo at the main referral hospital in a-zaz (al ahly hospital)
output 1.1:** al ahly hospital is equipped with one new and reliable ct scanner
output 1.2:** medical staff is available and trained in order to conduct enhanced diagnosis services at al ahly hospital in a'zaz
outcome 2: the emergency and mid-term wash needs of the population of aghtrin and suran sub-districts in aleppo governorate are met through improved access to safe drinking water & access to improved sanitation services
output 2.1:** rehabilitation and operation of water systems in a-zaz.
output 2.2:** rehabilitated sewage system networks in a-zaz
output 2.3:** increased capacity of local council to implement solid waste management system
output 2.4: beneficiaries have increased awareness and adoption of good hygiene and sanitation practices in a-zaz and al bab
proposed intervention description:
the proposed project contributed towards strengthening the delivery of wash and health services for conflict-affect population in aleppo (a-zaz, aghtrin, suran and maree sub-districts). world vision implemented this project directly with its staff on the ground and in coordination with the local councils, the water units and the health directorate. the health activities aimed to reduce complications from common illnesses, trauma, chronic and acute diseases in a-zaz. procuring and installing a ct scan is expected to improve the quality of primary health care integrated with trauma and chronic disease management services in jarablus. a ct scan was procured in turkey and sent to syria to jarablus hospital serving 20 patients a day. to operate and run the radiology unit, one radiologist and two radiologist assistants will be recruited and trained on the use of ct scan but also on humanitarian principles and referral mechanisms to/from other health facilities. the project also covered the salary of the recruited medical staff.
the wash activities focused on infrastructural activities to serve the emergency and mid-term wash needs of the population of aghtrin, suran and maree sub-districts in aleppo governorate. to increase access to safe drinking water and decrease the water borne diseases, the project will rehabilitate six water systems. the water systems were operated and maintained and water was tested. this project took a sustainable approach to transition operations and maintenance (o&m) to local water authorities by slowly decreasing the percentage of o&m support over several months with the aim to handover o&m fully to local authorities by project completion. to complement this transition, water authorities were trained in operating the water systems and in water quality treatment. to increase access to sanitation services, this project rehabilitated and extended existing sewage system networks, rehabilitated landfills, distributed rubbish bins to communities and support garbage collection trucks with fuel and salaries for workers. these components also included training local authorities on a tariff system for garbage collection as well. finally, to increase awareness and good hygiene practices, hygiene promotions at community level were organized
indicators to be evaluated:

summary of objectives
description
indicators
outcome 1
strengthened the diagnostic capacity of the health system in rural aleppo specifically main referral hospital in jarablus city (jarablus hospital)
% of target population benefiting from the health services
increase of target population access to specialized health diagnostic services
outcome 2
improved access to safe drinking water & access to improved sanitation services in aghtrin and suran sub-districts in aleppo governorate
% of target hhs that use an improved drinking water source
% of population with access to improved sanitation facility
% of people benefiting from a cleaner environment as a result of solid waste disposal service at least twice per week
% increase in respondents who report washing hands in three out of five critical times
evaluation purpose, objectives and use

purpose
the final evaluation will be conducted to examine the efficiency, effectiveness, timeliness, relevance, and potential impact of the project, to allow measurement of project achievements and to provide recommendations for future similar projects. the evaluation should take into consideration the project duration, existing resources, political and environmental constraints. this evaluation will also identify strengths and weaknesses in the project design, strategy, and implementation as well as lessons learned.
the purpose of this evaluation is to:
· provide outcomes indicators measurement and comparison to baseline values;
· determine if the project has achieved its stated objectives and explain why/why not;
· determine the impact of the project in terms of sustained improvements achieved;
· provide recommendations on how to build on the achievements and the possible avenues/intended objectives and results of a second phase of the project
· document lessons learned, success stories, and good practices in order to maximize the experiences gained.
· identify areas where strategic collaboration could add value in a second phase of operations
the evaluation should focus on the efficiency, effectiveness, timeliness, relevance and potential impact of the project, specifically answering the following questions:
effectiveness: to what extent has the project achieved predicted results at outcome level? what changes have been observed in project indicators since baseline and what has been the reasons for this change? how effective have beneficiary accountability mechanisms been?
relevance: was the project-s design adequate to address the problem(s) at hand? to what extent was the project sensitive to the different needs of women, men, girls and boys and to vulnerable groups in the population?
efficiency: were project results achieved in the most efficient and cost-effective way? to what extent has partner coordination helped or hindered the efficiency of the project?
impact: what have the wider intended and unintended effects of the project been on individuals, households, targeted communities and institutions? how likely is it that the impact of the project will be sustained after the project ends and why?
after examining the findings according to the evaluation criteria, lessons learned and recommendations should be drawn. the consultant should provide information on the economic/political/financial conditions that should exist, staff and partner capacities, required stakeholder participation, and other factors that should be in place to inform the design of future operations.
developing the measurement and analytical framework to refine and operationalize the questions posted above, will be done in close cooperation between world vision and the consultant.
evaluation users:

this evaluation will be used to:
· support accountability of wvi vis-à-vis the donor on the outcomes of the action and the usage of the funds provided through the provision of the evaluation report.
· support learning on the management of the project through the process of the evaluation and the discussion of the evaluation results.
the evaluation will serve as a learning resource providing evidence for planning, programming and replication of similar interventions for the following local and international stakeholders:
donor: the evaluation will be submitted to bmz to highlight the effectiveness and impact of the implemented project. the report will show to what extent the objective and the respective sub-objectives are met. it offers the opportunity for wvi to be accountable towards the its donors as the process will be documented in details and information will be generated based on the perception of the community.
wv germany: as the support office is in direct contact with bmz, the evaluation report will also be presented to wv germany to show the effectiveness and impact of the implemented project and highlight any challenges faced at the level of implementation. the support office will be also engaged in the evaluation process by providing feedback and approval on the tor as well as the evaluation report.
wvi syria office: the data collected from the evaluation will inform wvi on the technical and operational successes and challenges faced throughout the program implementation. the evaluation will further contribute to generating lessons learned and recommendations that should guide future similar interventions.
main partners and collaborators who will first be involved in the evaluation process and provide valuable input throughout the process about their collaboration with wvi and their experience in the project as a whole.

the finding will also be useful for them as they provide information about the effectiveness and impact of the intervention in their community and recommendations that might be relevant to consider in the coming phase, after the project has ended.
the evaluation will also help ensuring accountability for all beneficiaries and community members in the areas of operations.
evaluation methodology

the evaluation methodology is informed by the m&e plan specified during program design; in particular the design should use the sampling approach, tools and methods used at baseline to enable statistically sound comparison of baseline and endline results, where feasible. due to the changes in project design since baseline the consultant is required to propose the most appropriate sampling and data collection approach that is sensitive to the revisions while producing statistically robust evidence. the evaluation methods should be a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods involving the relevant project stakeholders, and beneficiaries at the community level. data collection methods may include but are not limited to secondary data information (project documents will be provided by wvi), surveys with target population in villages, key informant interviews (kii) and focus group discussions (fgd) with main stakeholders.
primary data collection is expected to comply with recognized ethical principles. survey data are expected to be collected on smartphones or tablets, using odk, kobo, smap or similar applications, and processed electronically. the consultant will provide the cleaned primary data set to world vision and grants world vision rights of storage and further usage. the consultant is expected to:
· provide an inception report to be reviewed by national office, regional office and support office prior to data collection.
· provide a time schedule, a breakdown by location and a breakdown of resources needed for primary data collection in the locations covered under this project;
· hire, train and supervise enumerators, which must include both men and women, and care for their provisions and security;
· obtain the necessary permissions for gathering primary data from the relevant authorities.
mixed methods approach: the report should triangulate data from primary and secondary sources. the primary data are from quantitative and qualitative sources (listed above) that provide information from various beneficiary perspectives; the secondary data will be drawn from a review of key project documents.
secondary data collection: based on the agreed upon analytical framework, wvi will provide the consultant with access to project documents relevant for the evaluation. the consultant is expected to research and include additional secondary sources in the analysis as needed. world vision can support with relevant additional secondary sources as available.
primary data collection - sampling approach:
quantitative sampling: the evaluation should employ the household survey sampling methodology used at baseline to allow for comparison, where possible. during baseline a two-phased proportional stratified random sampling approach was used with the primary sampling unit being the household with a sample frame of total population of the original targeted communities per project/sector. the table below shows the sample drawn at baseline:
table 4: sampling frame at baseline
gov
district
intervention
sub-district
target communities
target
requied sample size
actual surveys
fgds
kiis
aleppo
a-zaz
wash
akhtreen
zayadiyeh
59, 900
140
140
4
6
akhtreen
140
140
4
3
turkmen bareh
140
140
3
2
suran
kafra
20, 700
138
138
6
11
kafr ghan
139
139
4
1
dweibeq
138
138
6
6
jarablus
health
jarablus
jarablus
64, 042
210
210
6
4
al bab*
126
0
0
0
ghandora*
84
84
3
4
total
144, 642
1255
1129
36
37
* communities not targeted by project after revision due to the security context
the consultant should adopt a sampling approach that mirrors the baseline sample so that statistical comparisons can be made, and in addition include a representative sample of the target communities added after baseline took place using the same two-phased proportional stratified random sampling approach
sample size: the below sample size equation is hereby suggested to calculate the required sample size for those communities not included at baseline
n = [ ] where:
z = the z-score corresponding to the degree of confidence with which it is desired to be able to conclude that an observed change of size for p and q would not have occurred by chance (z = 1.96)
p = estimated prevalence of indicator in the population (p = 50%)
q = 1-p, population not presenting with indicator
d= design effect for a complex, clustered, sample (d = 2.0)
d = precision/margin of error, as fraction of 1 (d = 5%)
the estimated level of an indicator to be measured as a proportion is 0.5 (p1 =0.5), which is the most conservative assumption. a confidence level of 95% (z = 1.96) and a design effect of 2.0 is used, with a margin of error of 5% incorporated. using the sample size formula above plus with 10% oversample, in each sub-district table 5 outlines the sample to be drawn from communities that were not included at baseline:
table 5: sample size for wvi intervention communities without baseline data
governorate
district
sub-district
community
beneficiaries reached
sample size
maree
eastern countryside of marie
17, 876
415
akhtarin
ghroor
5, 250
419
arshaf
8, 994
tal a'ar
15, 434
sandara
7, 000
dodian
8, 000
it should be noted that since the activities in this project have benefitted both host communities and idps, the sample must include both groups proportionally.
given the short-term interventions in sr intervention villages it is suggested that a qualitative approach is taken in these villages (see project description for details of these communities)
qualitative sampling:
key informant interviews: key informant interviews should be conducted with stakeholders including members of local councils, water station engineers, hospital managers, medical staff and project staff. while the evaluator is not required to use identical kii sampling frame to baseline, deviation should be justified. for reference, 37 kiis were conducted at baseline, and distributed as illustrated in the table 4 above.
focus group discussions: focus group discussions should be conducted to gain a deep understanding of beneficiary perspective and explanations of change and their

Documents

Tender Notice
Login to view

Jordan Public Procurement Intelligence

Frequently asked questions

The bid deadline for Consultancy Firm to Provide End of Project Evaluation was 07 Apr 2019. Bidding is closed.

This tender has been issued by WORLD VISION INTERNATIONAL in Jordan.

The tender value is not disclosed; please refer to the tender document. EMD / bid security details are provided in the tender document.

This tender is financed by Other Funding Agencies.

The tender is classified under the following CPV code(s): 79900000 - Miscellaneous business and business-related services.

The tender notice and related documents are listed in the Documents section above. Select a document to view or download it. Please log in or register to access the documents. If you cannot find additional documents in the Documents section, please log in to your account and Send Document Request from your account section.

The TendersOnTime reference is 31948569. The purchaser document reference is not provided in the notice.

Browse other tenders from Jordan or search by relevant keywords and CPV classification.

This tender falls under Defence and Security, Printing and Publishing in Jordan. Suppliers in these sectors can track similar Jordan tenders using CPV-based alerts.